Airframe Technology: Embraer’s New Executive Jet Assembly Facility
Often our own work experience shapes our perspective of the industry, creating a myopic view of our huge, diverse industry. Mine was developed early on while working in the airline industry where work places were often huge old military or manufacturing spaces that were noisy, dusty, hot or cold depending on the day or season, and staffed by multitudes of seemingly frenetic employees.
This version was soon to be upgraded when Embraer’s media relations manager for North America Elisa Donel, invited AMT magazine to attend the news media open house on Sept. 6 at Embraer’s Executive Jets Campus in Melbourne. Also attended by journalists, magazine editors, cameramen, and the local press, we got a briefing from the executive staff and a guided tour of the campus. We were treated like customers and all questions were answered.
Our briefing began with a presentation about the “Space Coast of Florida,” the Economic Development Commission (EDC) and Embraer’s collaborative efforts and negotiations necessary for Embraer to locate the Phenom 100 and 300 final assembly and paint facility and global customer center at Melbourne International Airport.
Embraer S.A.
Embraer is a multinational corporation headquartered in São José dos Campos, Brazil, that designs, develops, manufactures, and sells aircraft and systems for the commercial aviation, executive aviation, and defense and security segments. It is the world’s largest manufacturer of commercial jets up to 120 seats, with offices and operations in six countries including the U.S. for 33 years.
Founded in 1969, Embraer has a workforce of about 18,000 employees and its firm order backlog is around 16 billion USD. In 2004-2005, a 10-year market assessment showed a potential for 8,500 business jets worth 138 billion USD so in 2005, Embraer formed Embraer Executive Jets to compete in the entry-level and light jet segments with the Phenom 100 and Phenon 300. Its assessment appears to be on track. In a recent web cast, Embraer discussed its 2012 second quarter performance numbers: 20 jets were delivered to the executive aviation market, 17 of those were light jets (seven Phenom 100s delivered from Melbourne, 10 Phenom 300s).
In today’s economics those are great numbers but could be better according to Ernie Edwards, head of Embraer's Executive Jets business. Edwards told Reuters in an interview at the August Latin American Business Aviation Conference and Exhibition (LABACE) in São Paulo, Brazil, that, “Embraer wants 30 percent of the business jet market” and it appears that the Phenom series is the airplane that will help get that 30 percent and maybe more.
The Phenom 100 and the 300 are entry-level jets and were designed specifically to compete in the single-pilot executive and business market. The 100 has a capacity for four passengers, the 300 holds six. About 240 Phenom 100s have been sold and there is a nice back order.
This aircraft is what the Embraer staff call a “clean-sheet” design and represents true innovations in business jets. It is not a scaled down version of other company aircraft.
Melbourne Executive Jet Campus and staff
Embraer’s Executive Jet Campus houses the Phenom assembly facilities, global customer center and the future engineering and technology center to be completed in 2014. The tour of the Melbourne Campus was a high-voltage jolt to my mental model of our aviation industry. The Embraer campus was a “green-field project” and all the new buildings and their interior could be featured on the pages of Architectural Digest. The assembly facility was like no other that I have ever worked in, visited, or read about.
Working from a “clean sheet” is how Phil Krull, managing director, Melbourne Operation, described the campus design philosophy. The final assembly facility in particular is bright, air-conditioned, impossibly clean, and quiet. It is a very high-tech facility using the latest computer systems, manufacturing tools, jigs, fixtures and processes. In a prior phone interview Krull stated, “We are justly proud of this facility in which we combined highly educated, high-tech people with advanced production techniques that are on the leading edge of modern aircraft production.”
Total staffing as of July 2012 was 208 employees: 164 in the assembly facility and 44 in the customer service center. According to Krull, “We have a very diverse and talented workforce here at our Melbourne facility. Our technicians average about 17 years of experience. We have 160 production employees and 40 of these are former NASA contractors. Some were recruited from competitors, local companies and different branches of the military.
"Each new hire had four weeks of training that included lean manufacturing process, continuous improvement concepts, safety, and other technical courses provided in-house and through Brevard Community College. Technicians that operate special tools, fixtures, and machines had an additional six weeks of intense hands-on training at the Embraer Aircraft Manufacturing facility in Gavião Peixoto, Brazil.”
All executives and staff stated that “their success at the Melbourne assembly facility was due to the ease of acculturation with their Brazilian counter parts and the exceptional level of teamwork between the two work groups.”
Final assembly line
This modern facility can produce both the Phenom 100 and 300 in single-line configuration. Currently160 technicians working two shifts are producing two Phenom 100s a month and, depending on economics and customer demand, could increase that rate to eight per month.
Production of the Phenom 100 began in June of 2011 and to date, 14 Phenom 100s have been produced and eight delivered. In the afternoon of our tour the executives announced that two more Phenom 100s had been sold that day. This September, the Phenom 300 assembly started in Melbourne, with its first delivery expected in 1Q2013.
The fuselage, empennage, and wing assemblies for the 100 and 300s are built in Brazil and shipped in very large boxes via sea and land freight to the Melbourne assembly facility. There assemblers install windows, landing gears, all systems, flight deck equipment, instrument panels, engines, and the customer’s choice of interiors and paint scheme. The aircraft components, piece parts, hardware, and support equipment are clearly marked and strategically placed at each of the five assembly stations. The aircraft in work moves one station every seven days.
On tour, I did not see or hear hand drills, impact wrenches, rivet guns, or service units; no aircraft engines running up or planes taxiing by and most notably, no technicians shouting to be heard over the din of it all. The facility appeared to be staffed by a small number of young, diverse assemblers and support specialists who were friendly and usually presented big smiles as we walked by their workstations.
Paperless assembly
The Melbourne facility is conducting the beta test for Embraer’s first “paperless” production line and one that “uses leaner, cleaner, and faster assembly process.” I found this “paperless” line concept intriguing. Granted it was a few years back, but my experience in heavy jet overhaul and light manufacturing was that before the aircraft or part could be released for service, the associated paperwork had to equal the weight of the aircraft or part.
When asked for more details, Krull gave us an ample description of Embraer’s Manufacturing Execution System (MES). “It is a computer-controlled, browser-based data collection and reporting system that supports RF handheld intelligent devices and barcode scanners. Embraer staff use a tablet and pen stylus for entering and retrieving information when at workstations, in and around the Phenom production line.”
Some examples of information contained in the MES system are work instructions, specifications, or data from a component being installed. When the technicians are working away from plane side, they use kiosks with large screens and keyboards. The MES system collects data about process, quality, downtimes, and maintenance. Krull said that one of the “challenges” was translating all the technical documentation from Portuguese to English. As we toured the assembly area, we saw many assemblers using the MES. In addition to having this technology available, the engineers and production control support staff are located a short distance from the production line.
Mark Miller, production operations manager, was one of our tour guides and when asked how well the assembly process all worked said, “There had been a few challenges early on but they had quickly worked through those and now operations were very smooth. Current production was just a bit ahead of schedule.”
He also casually mentioned that in December 2011 when operations and flight tests were completed on the first Melbourne-made Phenom 100 pushed out the door, all operating requirements were met and there were zero discrepancies, no squawks. He said that the Phenom had met their expectations and set the bar for quality. We also had an opportunity to look at the paint hangar and other employee spaces and common areas. The huge negative-pressure paint hangar was exceedingly clean. The employee café and restrooms were just as bright, colorful, and clean and organized as the production floor.
I mentioned my observations of the café and restrooms to Krull and he said that represented Embraer's commitment to a culture of respect for their employees and to ensure that Embraer is a great place to work. As we toured the Embraer campus, Krull pointed out the common areas including ball courts, walking paths, and covered sitting and eating areas.
To paraphrase several of the Embraer Executive Jet executives: We are American first and foremost but aviation is a global business. We work for a global company that is very successful, has a culture of inclusion and cooperation, builds beautiful products, has competitive compensation rates, and creates great places for us to work. Maggie Laureano, VP of human resources, states that one of the corporate goals was to create a happy workplace at the Embraer Campus in Melbourne.
After touring Embraer’s Executive Jet Campus and visiting with the employees, my mental model of our industry changed considerably. My hope is that the Embraer culture and the facility in Melbourne become the model for future aviation workplaces. I saw quite a few assemblers that looked quite happy working in a quiet, clean, air-conditioned building on small, beautiful jets.
Space Coast of Florida and the Economic Development Commission (EDC)
The Space Coast is a region on the west coast of Florida that includes the cities of Cape Canaveral, Palm Bay, Cocoa, Cocoa Beach, Titusville, Rockledge, and Melbourne. The Economic Development Corporation (EDC) is a development organization created to secure Florida’s position as one of the global leaders in aerospace research, investment, exploration and commerce. The CEO for the EDC of Florida’s Space Coast is the dynamic Lynda Weatherman whose job is to liaison between legislators and key business sector associations and companies, developing incentives and policies to strengthen Brevard County's and Melbourne’s business environment.
According to Weatherman, one of her “most challenging jobs was to convince the EDC to trust her and put together a large package of incentives necessary to attract a very successful aviation company to the Melbourne International Airport, that insisted on remaining anonymous until late in the negotiations.”
After careful consideration regarding their long-term business plan and the incentives offered by the Space Coast’s EDC, Embraer did select that location for its Executive Jets headquarters. On Dec. 4, 2008, Embraer broke ground for its first U.S. aircraft final assembly plant where Phenon 100 production started in June 2011 with first delivery in December 2011. Phenom 300 assembly began in September; first delivery expected 1Q2013.
On Dec. 5, 2011, Embraer Executive Jets opened its Global Customer Center where Embraer’s global customers can design their executive jet’s interior using high-end 3-D technology and showrooms with extensive collections of interior finishing materials. The aircraft and interior are certified at the same time. The delivery suites in this facility provide a dramatic back drop for customers to see their completed U.S.-assembled Phenom 100 and in 1Q2013, their new 300.
Then on March 21, 2012, Florida’s Governor Rick Scott announced that “Embraer will be adding a new research and development facility. The Embraer Engineering and Technology Center USA will be housed in a 67,000-square-foot facility to be constructed at the Melbourne International Airport on the site of the current Embraer Executive Jets Division Headquarters and final assembly building.”
The Phenom 100
The Phenom 100 is an entry-level jet for the executive and business aircraft market. It is not a scaled down version of another Embraer aircraft and represents true innovation in design and operation. Embraer engineers must have spent many, many hours thinking about the pilots and passengers and the AMTs who would be maintaining the aircraft. This is very obvious when you see the aircraft for the first time and especially so, when you look in the cockpit and passenger cabin. From the outside you notice that the fuselage sits on top of the wing giving more space in the cabin. The nacelles are high and away from baggage doors, ramp service activities and mission stopping FOD. The cabin materials are luxurious and the workmanship is elegant. Design partner BMW Group Designworks USA included many unique features for the comfort and convenience of the passengers. The best is the very large, tall windows that provide passengers with an excellent outside view and give the cabin an overall light and spacious feel.
When you look in the cockpit and review the check list, you quickly see that instrumentation and operations have been drastically reduced and systems truly automated. The reduction in the number of traditional gauges, switches and systems automation gives the aircraft an almost automotive philosophy. That is - get in, start the engines, check for warning lights and drive (fly) away. The preflight procedure is simple: turn the two battery switches to ON and the three display screens of the Garmin Prodigy 100 system initialize; rotate one of the engine control knobs to start. The beacon illuminates and stays on until the engines are shut down. The accessories and pressurization system automatically perform self checks. If no problems appear on the displays, the pilot calls ground control for instructions and begins taxing to the runway.
The Phenom engineers have designed a very maintenance-friendly aircraft. The airframe is robust, systems are simplified and automated. The components and LRU have easy access and when a failure does occur can be fixed or replaced quickly. “All components and sensors such as the stall warning, pitot-static, standby electric fuel pumps and so on can be removed and replaced from outside the airplane with no special tools.” The rugged design gives the aircraft a life limit of 35,000 hours or flight cycles. Maintenance inspection intervals are 600 hours or 12 months, with no other maintenance phase checks. For the U.S., maintenance support is provided at three Embraer-owned service centers in Florida, Connecticut, and Arizona and other independent Embraer-authorized service centers, plus numerous international service centers. Embraer offers owner and operators a fixed-by-the-hour, maintenance cost plans for the entire airplane and Pratt & Whitney does the same for the engines.
About the Author
Charles Chandler
Field Editor
Field Editor Charles Chandler has a Masters of Science Degree in Adult and Occupational Education with a major in Human Resources Development. He began his aviation career as a junior mechanic for American Airlines and retired after 27 years of service. After leaving American he held both line and staff positions in six other major companies. His positions with those companies included curriculum development specialist, manager and director for organizational development, management and leadership development, and maintenance training operations departments.