FAA Proposes $300,000 Civil Penalty Against American Airlines

The FAA alleges that on Feb. 2, 2009, American Airlines mechanics deferred maintenance on a McDonnell Douglas MD-82 under the airline’s DC-9 Minimum Equipment List (MEL) by noting that the “pitot/stall heater light off” light on the aircraft’s...


WASHINGTON – The Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) today announced that it is proposing a $300,000 civil penalty on American Airlines for a maintenance violation.

The FAA alleges that on Feb. 2, 2009, American Airlines mechanics deferred maintenance on a McDonnell Douglas MD-82 under the airline’s DC-9 Minimum Equipment List (MEL) by noting that the “pitot/stall heater light off” light on the aircraft’s annunciator panel was inoperative.

However, maintenance personnel determined the next day that the inoperative part was actually the captain’s pitot probe heater. Pitot probes are mounted on the exterior surfaces of an airplane and are used in measuring airspeed. Because they can be affected by a build-up of ice, these devices are equipped with heaters. The airplane’s MEL allows for maintenance on the pitot probe heater to be deferred, but it restricts flights to daytime only, in Visual Meteorological Conditions (VMC). It prohibits flights into known or forecast icing or visible moisture.

Because mechanics logged the discrepancy as an inoperative panel light, the flight crew was unaware that the daytime, VMC restrictions applied to further flights. The aircraft was operated on five passenger revenue flights, in violation of Federal Aviation Regulations.

"We expect full compliance with all of our maintenance standards," said FAA Administrator Randy Babbitt. "Safety is our top concern. Maintenance personnel must pay attention to every detail when they are working on an aircraft."

American Airlines has 30 days from the receipt of the FAA’s civil penalty letter to respond to the agency.

We Recommend

  • Press Release

    FAA Seeks Penalties Against American Airlines for Deferred Maintenance, Other Violations

    The FAA today announced actions totaling $7.1 million in civil penalties against American Airlines for improperly deferring maintenance on safety-related equipment and deficiencies with its drug and...

  • Article

    MEL magic - is it really airworthy?

    MEL Magic — Is It Really Airworthy? By Stephen P. Prentice May-June 1998 Steve Prentice is an attorney whose practice involves FAA-NTSB issues. He has an Airframe and Powerplant...

  • Article

    Minimum Equipment Lists

    Minimum Equipment Lists Why they exist and what they cover By Jack Hessburg October 2000 Not every device installed on an airplane works all the time. Items of installed...

  • Article

    A Look at FAR 43.13(a)

    Performing maintenance or not performing maintenance, you’re still accountable