MIAMI TWP., Montgomery County -- A state representative will rally Ohio lawmakers to declare the Wright brothers the first in fly an airplane after the state of Connecticut contended Gustave Whitehead beat the Dayton brothers in flight by two years.
Rep. Rick Perales, R-Beavercreek, made the announcement Thursday standing in front of a "look-a-like" Wright B Flyer in a hangar at the Dayton-Wright Brothers Airport.
Perales and North Carolina state Sen. Bill Cook, who joined the press conference via a teleconference from Kill Devil Hills, N.C., refuted claims Whitehead was the first to fly and made clear they took offense Connecticut passed a law in June that credited Whitehead with the first flight on Aug. 14, 1901.
Orville and Wilbur Wright took flight on the sand dunes of Kitty Hawk, N.C., on Dec. 17, 1903.
"It's wrong for one state to distort history. I believe it's just as wrong for other states to accept it in silence," Perales said. "Wilbur and Orville were Ohioans, and Ohio needs to stand by them and speak up for them."
The two discredited a blurry image in a photograph that purportedly shows the aircraft Whitehead flew and more than century-old news accounts of a 1901 Whitehead flight reported in a Bridgeport, Conn., newspaper that was picked up and repeated as fact.
"This thing is more like a fairy tale told to a child," Cook said. "It's ridiculous."
Thirty-four aviation historians signed a statement refuting the Whitehead claim, officials said. The statement said Whitehead's purported flight was based on "a single flawed news article combined with questionable witness testimony gathered more than thirty years after the fact" and a photographic image that was "totally discredited" and "proven to not be of Whitehead's machine."
Connecticut state Rep. Larry Miller, who believes the historical record shows Whitehead made aviation history in the lawmaker's home district, introduced the resolution in his state that legislators made law this summer.
"We're not distorting history," he said Thursday in a telephone interview. "We want history to be accurate. ... We're not just blowing our horn. We've got documentation on this."
Miller said dozens of people signed witness affidavits in the two years Whitehead allegedly flew prior to the Wright brothers' flight, and a replica of his No. 21 plane has been flown by an enthusiast group.
"We're not trying to do anything to discourage or make the Wright brothers look bad, but they were savvy businessmen, understand that," Miller said.
He also dismissed historians' contention the Wright brothers made history first.
"We must have 20 or 30 cabinets of historical data in Connecticut," he said. "These guys are welcome to come to Connecticut and research it."
While Ohio and North Carolina have often been rivals over who could claim the Wright brothers, this time the two states stood united, Perales and Cook said.
"For us to come together on anything much less aviation, much less the Wright Brothers, I think is astounding, it's humorous, but it's powerful," Perales said.
Amanda Wright Lane, the grandniece of the Wright brothers, said her uncles' aviation accomplishments are well documented.
"They were so well-documented, so well-recorded for history, I think there's no doubt their research was the basis for the science of aeronautics," she said.
The decades-old controversy and rivalry between the Wright brothers and Whitehead, a German immigrant, was revived this year when Jane's All the World's Aircraft, considered the bible of aviation, declared the evidence showed Whitehead should be credited for the first flight. An attempt to reach Jane's editor Paul Jackson was unsuccessful Thursday. Australian researcher John Brown has been credited with reviving interest in the contention Whitehead flew first.
In a telephone interview Thursday from Munich, Germany, Brown said his findings were based on both circumstantial and direct evidence that showed "well beyond a shadow of a doubt" Whitehead flew first.
By Tom Hendershot As AMTs of today we work with many different types of people who make up our profession. We know about our fellow co-workers, personally and professionally. But have you ever...
Charles E. Taylor is aviation's forgotten man. But not to U.S. aircraft mechanics, nor to Virginia Krause-Hess.
Charles E. Taylor, born May 24, 1868 on a farm in Illinois, was involved in many historical events related to the growth of aviation.
On Tuesday March 2, 2010, the U.S. Air Force Academy accepted a bronze bust of Charles E. Taylor from the Aircraft Maintenance Technicians Association.