Lidle's Widow Sues Insurer

Melanie Lidle is entitled to the $1.05 million payout because the life insurer can't prove that Cory Lidle was piloting the single-engine Cirrus SR-20 plane that crashed into a Manhattan high-rise.


The widow of New York Yankees pitcher Cory Lidle has sued MetLife Inc. claiming she is owed more than $1 million under baseball's benefit plan.

Lidle died in the crash of his small plane Oct. 11 and was covered by the benefit plan of Major League Baseball and its players' association, which had a $450,000 life insurance benefit and an accidental death benefit of $1.05 million.

However, the plan - which applies to all players with major league contracts - contains an exclusion for "any incident related to travel in an aircraft ... while acting in any capacity other than as a passenger."

New York-based MetLife paid Melanie Lidle $450,000, but "has refused to pay the entirety of the policy" despite demands, according to the lawsuit filed in Los Angeles County Superior Court. The family lived in suburban Glendora, Calif., during the offseason

In the complaint, lawyers for Melanie Lidle said they anticipate MetLife will try to claim that Lidle's death occurred while he was acting in the role of pilot, crew member or another capacity and not a passenger.

Melanie Lidle is entitled to the $1.05 million payout because the life insurer can't prove that Cory Lidle was piloting the single-engine Cirrus SR-20 plane that crashed into a Manhattan high-rise, said her lawyer, Stacy King.

"Quite frankly, there were no eyewitnesses that we've been able to find to determine who actually was flying that plane," King said Monday.

The complaint was filed March 9. A status conference hearing is set for July 31, King said.

MetLife spokesman John Calagna said the company does not comment on ongoing litigation.

The 34-year-old Lidle and flight instructor Tyler Stanger were killed when the pitcher's plane slammed into an apartment tower during a midday aerial tour past the Statue of Liberty and north up the East River.

An investigation by the National Transportation Safety Board found neither men had drugs or alcohol in their systems. However, the agency did not reach any conclusions about the cause of the accident or who was at the controls when the plane crashed.

Last month, the Lidle and Stanger families filed wrongful-death lawsuits against California-based Cirrus Design Corp., the maker of the airplane. The lawsuits allege product liability, negligence and other complaints.

On Feb. 28, dentist Lawrence Rosenthal, who lived in the high-rise, filed a $7 million lawsuit against Cory's estate, claiming his 43rd-floor apartment was destroyed in the crash.

Lidle pitched for seven teams during his nearly 10-year major league career, going 82-72 with a 4.57 ERA.


Copyright 2005 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

News stories provided by third parties are not edited by "Site Publication" staff. For suggestions and comments, please click the Contact link at the bottom of this page.

We Recommend

  • Press Release

    Lidle's Widow Sues Insurer

    Melanie Lidle is entitled to the $1.05 million payout because the life insurer can't prove that Cory Lidle was piloting the single-engine Cirrus SR-20 plane that crashed into a Manhattan high-rise.

  • Press Release

    Yankees Pitcher Crash Gets Final Hearing

    NTSB to meet today to review a final report on the accident, but documents show investigators have had surprisingly little to go on.

  • News

    NTSB: Lidle or Co-Pilot Misjudged U-Turn

    The NTSB investigators said they still do not know whether Corey Lidle, a pitcher for the New York Yankees, or his flight instructor was piloting the plane at the time of the Oct. 11, 2006, crash.

  • News

    Pilot Error in Yankees Pitcher Crash

    The families fault the Cirrus SR-20's steering mechanism, though the NTSB found no evidence of system, structure or engine malfunction.