Dispute Continues to Snowball: Minnesota Tosses Out Ideas on Love Field Restrictions

Though it would be hard to match the passion of North Texans in the fight over the Wright amendment, some Minnesotans have their own ideas on repealing the 1979 law.


WASHINGTON - The Lone Star debate over long-haul flights at Dallas Love Field has stirred the interest of some in the North Star state.

Though it would be hard to match the passion of North Texans in the fight over the Wright amendment, some Minnesotans have their own ideas on repealing the 1979 law.

So far, their efforts to trade support for repealing Wright haven't yielded Southwest Airlines Co. flights to faraway Duluth or Rochester or to Minneapolis, for that matter.

But interest in Minnesota illustrates how Wright isn't just a local issue for Dallas-Fort Worth. Officials in Omaha, Neb., staked out a position favoring repeal, for example, but some in Toledo, Ohio, oppose changing the law.

Much of the recent chatter in Minnesota was sparked by an editorial in The Duluth News Tribune headlined: "With a Little Love, Duluth Could Land Another Airline."

That new airline would be Dallas-based Southwest, which is leading the fight to repeal Wright. Duluth now relies on Northwest Airlines Inc. and its regional partners for the bulk of its flights.

The newspaper reported that it enlisted the help of Sen. Mark Dayton, D-Minn., to organize other members in the state's congressional delegation to back the repeal in return for Southwest service to Duluth and Rochester.

"Favor-trading is hardly an unfamiliar concept in Congress, and it won't be long before members representing other states latch onto this idea," the newspaper reasoned. "Here's a chance for the Minnesota delegation to right that wrong while bringing a needed service to constituents."

Southwest's vantage

Southwest officials are usually coy about plans to enter markets.

They acknowledge Minneapolis would make an attractive addition to their route system but deny lobbying the Minnesota delegation with promises of flights in return for votes to repeal the Wright amendment.

The carrier is very active in the Midwest, and Chicago's Midway Airport is expected to become Southwest's biggest operation this year.

Typically, Southwest adds cities using a rigorous process based on traffic volume and, most important, potential profits.

"We were flattered by that editorial," said Ron Ricks, a Southwest senior vice president. But "our route-planning people would say that Minnesota is a little bit far off in our plans."

Landing with a thud

Indeed, the campaign ran out of steam about the time the newspaper landed on Duluth doorsteps.

"It was a most unfortunate editorial," said Rep. James Oberstar, Duluth's local congressman and the ranking Democrat on the House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee.

For the record, he is a solid supporter of American Airlines Inc. Like the Fort Worth-based carrier, he adamantly opposes repealing Wright. And he is not about to switch his loyalty, even for new flights to his state.

"I would not do it on that basis ever. It would compromise the ethics of the legislative process," Mr. Oberstar said.

Brian Ryks, executive director of the Duluth International Airport, said he would love to see Southwest start service. But he said the airline typically serves markets of more than 1 million, making it unlikely they would start flights for Duluth's 85,556 residents.

In fact, American's regional partner twice in the last five years started and then abandoned service between Duluth and Chicago.

The editorial was penned by Robin Washington, editorial page editor of The News Tribune.

Mr. Washington said he got the idea in December after Southwest's accident in Chicago prompted him to check out the carrier's Web site, where he learned about Southwest's battle against Wright.

Now he argues that residents in Minneapolis-St. Paul would gladly make the two-hour-plus drive to Duluth to take advantage of Southwest's lower fares.

"If I was in the Twin Cities and I could use Southwest, I think I might want to do it," Mr. Washington said.

For his part, Mr. Dayton declines to discuss his conversation with his local newspaper.

This content continues onto the next page...

We Recommend