Spotlight on Indonesia Aviation Safety

March 9, 2007
Indonesia's safety record in 2007 was worse than the average African nation, according to Ascend, a London-based global aviation consultancy firm.

One Indonesian jetliner plunged to sea from 35,000 feet, killing everyone on board. Another's fuselage split in half after a hard landing. This week, a Boeing 737 careened off a runway and burst into flames, leaving 21 people dead.

Three accidents in as many months have raised urgent concerns about the safety of Indonesia's booming airline sector, with experts saying poor maintenance, rule-bending and a shortage of trained professionals may be behind the disasters.

Dozens of airlines emerged after Indonesia deregulated its aviation industry in the 1990s, making air travel affordable for the first time for many across the sprawling island nation, and luring passengers away from ferries and trains.

Passenger numbers have risen more than 20 percent every year since 2000, putting the system under strain, according to the Indonesia's Directorate General of Civil Aviation.

Last year, a plane crashed, had a near-miss, skipped a runway, made an emergency landing or reported a technical problem every 12 days on average, government statistics show.

"I'm terrified to fly," said Barry Tontey, 50, who lost his daughter in the New Year's Day crash at sea. She was supposed to graduate from medical school in July.

"I don't believe the government or the airlines are committed to safety," he said.

Indonesia's safety record in 2007 was worse than the average African nation, according to Ascend, a London-based global aviation consultancy firm, basing its figures on the rate of passengers killed per million departures.

"Fixing a safety record is a long-term cultural challenge" that requires improving discipline and communication between pilots and crews, said Martin Craigs, president of Hong Kong-based Aerospace Forum Asia. "It's not about quickly ticking boxes in a technical manual ... It's got to be inbred in the system."

Investigators probing Wednesday's crash-landing of a Garuda Airline jetliner said its front wheels snapped off as it touched down, but declined to speculate on the cause of the accident.

Garuda has had nine plane crashes in the past 30 years, killing 330 people, but has made progress recently in improving its safety regulations and training of pilots, experts said. Before Wednesday, its last major incident was in 2002, when a plane made an emergency landing on a river, with the loss of one life.

"As a whole, it is one of the best airlines in Indonesia, probably the best," said aviation analyst Dudi Sudibyo.

The flight data recorders of the Adam Air plane that crashed into the sea on New Year's Day, killing all 102 people on board, have not yet been recovered and the wreckage is still lying on the ocean floor. And when another of the airline's planes broke apart on landing weeks later, without causing serious injuries, company spokeswoman Natalia Budihardjo tried to downplay the incident, at one point telling a reporter it was "normal."

Video footage taken by a passenger aired on local television Thursday showed panicked passengers on another budget carrier, Lion Air, taking safety into their own hands this week. They scrambled to put on life vests after the jet hit heavy turbulence, ignoring flight attendants' pleas that they not do so.

The main concern, experts say, is failure by air carriers and aviation officials to comply with Indonesia's regulations, which are considered by the U.S. Federal Aviation Administration to be quite strong.

"There is always collusion between operators and regulators," said Frans Wenas, the head of Indonesia's transport ministry's safety committee. "Sometimes we may uncover problems, and it's only on paper that they are rectified," he said. "There is no way I can check all the aircrafts."

When an accident does happen, it is rare that anyone is held accountable, adding to public mistrust. Often, proposals made by senior government officials after a crash fail to address the root problems.

Transport Minister Hatta Rajasa, who is also facing criticism over a string of ferry disasters, announced a plan last month to ban local carriers from operating jetliners more than a decade old as part of a new government safety campaign.

"It's ridiculous. By most standards a 10-year-old plane is new," said Patrick Smith, a U.S.-based airline pilot and aviation commentator, noting that if America implemented such a regulation, half its fleet would be grounded.

"It's not the age that matters, its how it is operated," he said. "That's what makes an airline safe."

Copyright 2005 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

News stories provided by third parties are not edited by "Site Publication" staff. For suggestions and comments, please click the Contact link at the bottom of this page.