An aircraft service center looking to expand its operation at Witham Field is meeting a wall of resistance from airport critics who say the county is giving it and other businesses deals that are far too sweet.

They say those businesses are paying rent far below the going rate for other tenants at the airport, including a nonprofit agency and the Martin County Sheriff's Office.

But airport businesses and the director of the airport said the critics are making an unfair comparison.

"It is definitely a fair lease for the county," said Dan Capen, president of the Stuart Jet Center, which will ask commissioners on Oct. 16 for permission to add 87,000-square-feet of hangars and offices to its Witham Field operation.

The business rents about 2.2 million square feet of land for about 7 cents per square foot per year. Another airport-related business, Galaxy Aviation, rents about 815,000 square feet of land for 7 cents per square foot per year.

Critics, who have vowed to fight Stuart Jet Center's expansion plan, say those leases are way too low.

"Seven cents is just ridiculous," said Jensen Beach activist Tony Parkinson. "There's something dreadfully wrong with all of this."

The sheriff's office pays about $5 per square foot annually to rent a 24,000-square-foot building for its records and human resources departments. The Council on Aging of Martin County pays about $9.50 per square foot for its 6,400- square-foot headquarters of the Community Coach bus transit system.

Dave Shore, president of the Witham Airport Action Majority group that opposes the expansion of the airport, called the business leases "sweetheart deals" that are cheating the taxpayers who own the airport.

"Here's an agency (Council on Aging) that helps our community and they are paying $9.50 when Stuart Jet and Galaxy are paying seven cents?" Shore said incredulously. "I mean come on.

"Our intent is to force Martin County to renegotiate the leases," Shore said. "I have spent the last week being outraged. The more I get involved in this issue, the angrier I get."

Difficult comparisons

Martin County Commissioner Lee Weberman said the county pays about $19 per square foot for the offices it rents around the county, such as the satellite offices for Tax Collector Larry O'Steen. He also criticized the leases for airport businesses and said he will ask officials to either look into whether they can be renegotiated.

"This almost looks like a subsidy," Weberman said. "We shouldn't be entering into these one-sided deals."

Capen said the critics are unfairly comparing two different kinds of leases. The sheriff's office and Council on Aging are renting already constructed buildings ready to be used on much smaller plots of land.

The Stuart Jet Center rented nearly 51 acres of land and had to spend about $11 million to build all of the roads, water and sewer lines and buildings on the property. Even though the businesses paid to construct all the buildings, the county gets ownership of them for free as part of the lease, Capen said.

"They're not comparing apples to apples," Capen said. "That's an $11 million investment that reverts to the county."

The businesses make other payments in addition to their rents, said Airport Director Mike Moon. Stuart Jet Center and Galaxy Aviation pay the county 8 cents for every gallon of fuel they sell to pilots. Vought Aircraft Industries pays the county half of the revenue it gets from subleasing its property.

Because of the large acreages rented and the additional payments, the three airport-related businesses pay far more per year than the Council on Aging, the Sheriff's Office, or the Witham Aero Club, a private club of recreational pilots that rents space for hangars. Vought will make the largest payment this year, about $517,000, according to county records, and the Stuart Jet Center will pay about $305,000.

The Council on Aging pays about $61,000 for its building.

Commission Chairman Michael DiTerlizzi said the fact that the county will get the buildings provided by the businesses makes the leases fairer than they may appear.

"When those leases were entered into in the 1990s nobody wanted the land," DiTerlizzi said.

Shore said Capen's argument was not valid because the leases for Stuart Jet Center and Galaxy Aviation do not expire until 2032. By then the buildings will have depreciated so much that they will be useless to the county, Shore said.

Companies won't renegotiate

The Witham Aero Club pays about 15 cents per square foot for land where it built hangars. Bob Blackford, the former president of the group, said that when he signed the lease in 1999 the rent was higher than what the club would have paid at St. Lucie County International Airport.

St. Lucie County charges about 5 cents per square foot for unimproved land at its airport and Indian River County charges 5 cents per square foot for unimproved airport land in Sebastian.

Blackford said Shore was just trying to find excuses to close Witham Field and was "scraping at the bottom of the barrel."

Weberman was critical of amendments that have been made to the leases. The original leases required Stuart Jet Center and Galaxy Aviation to pay the county 2 percent of the revenue the businesses got for subleasing the property. Commissioners dropped that requirement in 1999.

"It seems like every time we negotiate these leases they get more one sided,' said Weberman.

DiTerlizzi, who was elected in 2000, said he would not have voted to drop that requirement but he doesn't see how the county could get the businesses to agree to pay it again or renegotiate rents in the middle of the lease.

"This stinks of taking away property rights," DiTerlizzi said.

Capen said he "absolutely" will not renegotiate his lease with the county. Blackford said he didn't think any of the businesses would reopen their leases.

"It's like if you are renting a car for $500 and in the middle of the lease the car agency comes to you and says 'I need more money, my wife needs a new fur coat.' How interested are you going to be in renegotiating?" Blackford said.

Shore said the airport activists want commissioners to use the Stuart Jet Center's request to build more hangars as leverage against the business to force them to renegotiate.

Vought's lease expires in 2009 and the company will start renegotiating next year, said company spokeswoman Lynne Warne.

The Sheriff's Office is leaving its building on the airport by the end of the year. That building will be rented to another business or public agency, according to county officials.

DiTerlizzi said that building and any airport land rented in the future will be rented at fair market rates comparable to other airports and in the rest of the county.


Witham Field's leases

Leases at county-owned Witham Field are under fire, with opponents noting airport businesses are paying much less per square foot than a nonprofit agency and the sheriff's office. Airport business owners say the leases are not comparable.

Renter$ per s.f.$ totalAdditionalTotal $paymentsto countyCouncil on Aging$9.50$61,000N/A$61,000Sheriff's Office$5$120,000N/A$120,000Vought Aircraft15 cents$385,000*$132,000$517,000Witham Aero Club15 cents$19,000N/A$19,000Stuart Jet Center7 cents$151,000**$154,000$305,000Galaxy Aviation7 cents$57,000**$107,000$164,000$ per s.f.$ totalAdditionalTotal $paymentsto countyCouncil on AgingNonprofit6,400 square feet$9.50$61,000N/A$61,000Sheriff's Office$5$120,000N/A$120,000Vought Aircraft15 cents$385,000*$132,000$517,000Witham Aero Club15 cents$19,000N/A$19,000Stuart Jet Center7 cents$151,000**$154,000$305,000Galaxy Aviation7 cents$57,000**$107,000$164,000

* Vought Aircraft also pays the county 50% of the revenue the manufacturing company gets from subleasing some land to other companies, which is not included in the calculations of its rent.

** Stuart Jet Center and Galaxy Aviation also pay the county 8 cents per gallon of fuel that they sell as part of their leases, but that is not included in the calculations of their rents.

Source: Martin County