FAA Seeks Dramatic Revamp Of Pilot Training

Stall recovery at issue


May 12--WASHINGTON -- The Federal Aviation Administration on Wednesday proposed a dramatic revamping of airline pilot and crew training, a move that would turn many of the lessons learned from the February 2009 plane crash in Clarence Center into law.

Under the FAA proposal, for the first time, pilots would have to be trained to recover from the kind of stall that sent Continental Connection Flight 3407 plummeting into a house, killing 50 people.

They would have to be familiar with the stall-recovery equipment in the planes they fly, which the crew of Flight 3407 was not.

Unlike Capt. Marvin D. Renslow, pilot of the doomed plane, pilots could no longer fail flight tests and then receive no remedial training to make up for their deficiencies.

In addition, the rule would address many of the training problems pointed out in an award-winning Buffalo News series in December 2009, "Who's Flying Your Airplane?"

For example, pilots would have to be trained to fly in the weather conditions they are likely to experience in their jobs and would get simulator training on sudden emergency "upsets" and be required to recover from them.

"The FAA is proposing the most significant changes to air carrier training in 20 years. This is a major effort to strengthen the performance of pilots," said FAA Administrator Randy Babbitt.

Members of the Families of Continental Flight 3407, who pushed passage of a law that requires many of the changes in training, said the FAA proposal looks good to them, at least so far.

"While we are not in a position to give our wholehearted endorsement as of yet, at first glance, we are very pleased to see many of the deficiencies that contributed to Flight 3407 addressed," said Scott Maurer, of Moore, S.C., whose daughter, Lorin, was killed in the crash.

In general, the rule spells out a much more comprehensive training regimen that will better reflect real-world situations.

"Rather than just have a pilot execute a skill in isolation, the new training will require a more realistic and coordinated effort by the crew, as if they were on a real flight," Babbitt said. "It will be a lot more lifelike."

For one thing, crews will have to work together in their training regimens, just as they would in a flight.

And they will have to have additional experiences in the simulator that echo what could, in the worst-case scenario, happen in the cockpit of an airplane.

The FAA had long questioned the notion of training pilots in recovering from aerodynamic stalls, where a plane loses so much speed that its wings can no longer keep it aloft.

That's because pilots are supposed to never allow a plane to reach a stall in the first place, and because earlier-generation simulators were not able to mimic a full stall.

But thanks to new simulator technology, "now you can put someone in a stall scenario and let them recover," Babbitt said.

The National Transportation Safety Board blamed pilot error for the Clarence Center crash, and the biggest pilot error of all involved stall recovery.

Investigators found that Renslow pulled back on the plane's yoke when he should have pushed forward -- which could have been related to the fact that he had never received simulator training in the plane's stall-recovery system.

Such training would be required, though, under the FAA proposal, and Rep. Brian Higgins, D-Buffalo, said that only makes sense.

"Practical training encompassing potential emergency scenarios will help to better prepare skilled pilots entrusted with the lives of hundreds of people at 35,000 feet in the air," Higgins said.

Babbitt also stressed that the proposal requires remedial training for pilots such as Renslow, who show during test flights that their skills are lacking.

In addition, airlines will have to tailor their training to their flight routes. For example, airlines that fly in the Midwest would have to put a greater emphasis on flying in thunderstorms, while airlines flying in Alaska would have to pay more attention to training in flying in wintry conditions.

This content continues onto the next page...

We Recommend

  • News

    Cost issues may delay new pilot training rules

    -- Apr. 29--WASHINGTON -- The federal government's attempt to write new rules aimed at limiting pilot fatigue has hit a snag, and the group Families of Flight 3407 said Wednesday it is...

  • Press Release

    FAA Proposes Sweeping New Rule to Fight Pilot Fatigue

    The FAA proposes to set a nine-hour minimum opportunity for rest prior to the duty period, a one-hour increase over the current rules.

  • News

    Continental exec rebutted by lawmakers

    -- Jun. 17--WASHINGTON -- The chairman of Continental Airlines on Wednesday tried to wash his hands of responsibility for the February 2009 crash of Continental Connection Flight 3407 in...

  • Press Release

    FAA Issues Final Rule on Pilot Training

    Today's rule is one of several rulemakings required by the Act, including the requirements to prevent pilot fatigue that were finalized in December 2011, and the increased qualification requirements...