Management's Role in Maintenance Error Prevention

Management's Role in Maintenance Error Prevention By Richard Komarniski May 2000 Richard Komarniski is president of Grey Owl Aviation Consultants. He has worked as an Aircraft Maintenance Technician for the last 25 years holding AME and A&P...


Management's Role in Maintenance Error Prevention

By Richard Komarniski

May 2000

As a maintenance manager, you have to do your best to communicate with the owners or executive management to ensure you have the resources and the time to complete the assigned tasks. Management's role is not only to provide cost-efficient maintenance without any waste and with maximum production, but to also examine what actions we endorse and what actions we want others to emulate.

Reviewing the outcomes of some of the "classic" accidents involving maintenance shows that the maintenance manager, quality assurance manager, etc. were relieved of their duties because the company could not afford the culture and attitude they had fostered. This usually results from trying to make do and not giving the owners and executives a realistic picture of what is required to provide good maintenance from the very start. These managers then get caught in the vicious trap of trying to do more and more with less. Communications with senior management or executives can be challenging for many lower-level managers. How many of us are effective at telling our boss something they really do not want to hear, although we know they must hear it? Managers have to rely on their personal experiences, education, and training as well as their peers and subordinates to determine what needs to be done to improve an organization. But, is there an effective channel of communications to senior management? What can be done to improve the level of communication to the senior management regarding changes that are needed to be a successful organization? Do we have the training, tools, resources, policies, open lines of communication to foster the continuous improvement that is needed to survive in a highly competitive environment? If we communicate openly and honestly, we will gain the respect of the rest of the organization. This in turn dictates the attitude, morale, culture, and level of communications in an organization.

Setting the standard
As managers, we have to set the standard, and our attitudes will be mimicked throughout the organization. One senior manager told me that he asks his employees, "Tell me what I need to hear not what I want to hear."

Are we endorsing a positive environment where we are looking for the good in the individuals and the quality of the work that is being completed? Or, are we always looking for and reinforcing the negative in both the individuals and their work? The role of managers is to set the standards, communicate the standards and enforce them. We have to bring out the best in people and be prepared to listen.

Hiring quality
I see more companies spending time trying to assess the attitude of the potential employee before they are hired. As managers we have to examine the quality of people we hire. Many companies realize that "one bad apple in the barrel" can spoil all of them quickly.

Managers have to make an effort to communicate with their employees. We may have forgotten what it was like being on the shop floor relying on rumors to find out what the future holds. Failing to communicate effectively in the work place is directly linked with an increase in lack of cooperation, poor-quality work, low productivity, tension, gossip, rumors, increased turnover, absenteeism, and tardiness. When we do communicate, we should focus on the positive and acknowledge when a good job was done. When was the last time you said "great job" or even "thank you"? What effect would this have on each employee's self-esteem?

As mentioned earlier, when we read through accident reports or hear of an accident in the news, one of the repercussions of the accident is either a management shuffle or the managers responsible for the maintenance department are dismissed from the company. Unfortunately, it seems the easiest way to change the attitude fostered by a manager is to bring in new blood.

This content continues onto the next page...

We Recommend

  • Article

    What now?

    What Now? By Rich Komarniski February 1999 Richard Komarniski is President of Grey Owl Aviation Consultants. He has worked as an Aircraft Maintenance Technician for the last...

  • Article

    Error Prevention: Communication is key

    Human Factors Error Prevention Communication is key By Richard Komarniski October 2004 After attending several aviation conferences this summer, I realized that the...

  • Article

    Human Factors Awareness: Training and support equal prevention

    Human Factors Awareness Training and support equal prevention By Richard Komarniski T he only way to prevent the loss of lives and money that is caused by human error in the workplace...

  • Article

    The Supervisor's Role in Maintenance Error Prevention

    The Supervisor's Role in Maintenance Error Prevention By Richard Komarniski July 2000 Richard Komarniski is president of Grey Owl Aviation Consultants Inc. He has worked as an...